In the little over a year I’ve been doing this whole wrestling writing thing, one thing I’ve learned is that the best ideas are the ones that just randomly pop into my head.  The big ideas I plot and plan out for days ahead of time always seem to wind up falling flat – in fact, many of them never even make it to publication.  But the silly ones, like this ranking of WWE talents. .  These are the ones that seem to catch fire.

Welcome to part 2, which may or may not be the end of our list.  I fully intended this to be a one shot deal, but after realizing how much I was writing, I knew it had to be a multi-part epic.  If you missed part 1, may I kindly direct you here to catch up.

bit.ly/1SKxUGV

Gimmick Change Desperately Needed

28. Healthy Uso

I still couldn’t tell you which Uso is injured and which isn’t, nor could I tell you which one is married to Naomi.  I care very little for the Usos, as currently constituted, so much so that in hindsight, they definitely should have appeared in the first part of this list.

Having said all of that, I do think there’s a spot for them in WWE once Injured Uso makes his return, and yes, this is just a cheap excuse for me to break out another favorite stable idea.

Roman Reigns, at some point, is going to turn heel. It likely won’t be in 2015, though, since he’s got way too much legitimate popularity for that.  Still, when he does, he’s going to need to run a faction, and with the way he’s dressed, the perfect one would be a revision of the Samoan Swat Team.  Give the Usos matching black ring gear and let them be Reigns’ accomplices.  Despite the fact that she’s Tongan, most people won’t notice that, so you could add Tamina in as well.

Whether or not that happens, and it likely won’t, the Usos will need some sort of adjustment when they make their return, just like our next tandem on the list.

27. Los Matadors

What in the world is this, WWE?  You’re not selling any El Torito merch, so why keep up this stable?  Is it just laziness – not wanting to think of something better?  Does someone owe Carlos Colon money or something?  Take the masks off these poor boys and let them make something of themselves!

Yes, I still like the idea of bringing back older brother / cousin Carlito and letting them be a stable. I also mentioned, in the previous piece, having Sin Cara lose the mask and be their manager. Really, at this point, isn’t anything better than what they’re doing.

Hmm, on second thought. . .

26. Fandango

I don’t remember who said it, whether it was on NAIpod or if Doc Manson said it, but somebody was talking about the absolute insanity of having a guy whose gimmick is SOLELY based on their ring entrance, and when he wrestles on RAW, you don’t show said entrance.  Boggles the mind.

I don’t have a great booking idea for Johnny Curtis, but he’s talented enough to get some sort of shot with WWE, even if he is already 34 years old.  This guy needs the Tyson Kidd NXT treatment, pronto.

25. Adam Rose

Here’s my conspiracy theory of the week.  Ray Lappan, the man known as Adam Rose, knew his character wasn’t going anywhere, so he took to Twitter to post some cryptic Leo Kruger tweets and try to get fan support to force WWE to change his gimmick.  WWE saw this, didn’t appreciate it, and gave him this really dumb “Beef Mode” gimmick as a punishment.  “You want different, now you’re different.  Deal with it.”

I’m sure that’s not at all what happened, but it entertains me, so I’ll stick with it.  Looks like we won’t get our #DarkRose member of the Wyatt Family, but at least this might mean he’ll be on RAW more frequently. . . Which is something.

In truth, I’m really surprised they put Brad Maddox in this tag team, and not Fandango.

24. Stardust

Remember, as I told you in yesterday’s column, most of these guys are talents I really like.  I’m a big Cody Rhodes fan, though I just happen to like 24 other guys better.

I even like the Stardust gimmick, especially now that he’s more Joker than crazy cosmonaut.  Still, once this whole Stephen Amell thing goes away, isn’t that when Cody Rhodes needs to come back?  I mean, it has to happen sometime, right?

23. Damien Sandow

If it weren’t for the sad state of Sandow’s current career curve, he’d be ranked much higher.  Had I done this list right after his black t-shirt promo, he’d likely have been in my top ten.  The number of times WWE seems to have dropped the ball on Damien is a little ridiculous.

I don’t know if this beat poet character is just a rumor or if it’s just a web thing, but Sandow has proved that when you give him a shot. . .Really, any shot that doesn’t involve Curtis Axel. . . he can make it work.  Just put him back on WWE television, guys.  Please?

22. Kane

Kane gets the top spot in this tier solely because there’s obviously going to be a resurgence of the Devil’s Favorite Demon, and considering that’ll likely be the last run of Glenn Jacob’s career, I’m looking forward to it.

This is the thing with WWE, and more specifically, with fans.  We forget that sometimes the bad versions of a character (bad as in not popular, not bad is in heelish) exist so that when they bring back the good (ie, beloved) version, the crowd will pop all the harder.

Trust me, if Kane comes out in the red and the mask, people are going to go crazy, both in the arena and on Twitter.

They are Fine Enough, I guess

These are the talents I like, though I’m not over the moon for any one of them.

21. Darren Young

I’ve never known what to make of Darren Young, besides the fact that he looks a whole lot like John Cena.  I’m happy enough with him as part of the Prime Time Players, but if and when they break up (and since you’ve hopefully read my work from Monday, you know when and why I think they should), I’m not sure where DY goes from there.

WWE doesn’t have the depth, creatively and booking-wise, to create a homosexual character that isn’t just a caricature.  Beef Mode, which I mentioned earlier, is the only way to know how to do it.  They don’t seem to understand that being gay, or being black, doesn’t have to be the entirety of a gimmick.  Bret Hart wasn’t just Canadian (except at the end) and Goldberg wasn’t just Jewish.  It was part of a bigger picture.

And this is coming from the guy who just pushed a Samoan and Puerto Rican stable.

20. Randy Orton

Like with Sandow, had this ranking been done around Wrestlemania time, Randy would have been higher.  Orton was on fire feuding with Rollins – passionate, dedicated, making every moment must-see.  Now, he’s feuding with Sheamus, and all of that passion seems to have dwindled rather quickly.

This, my friends, is Randy Orton.  When he’s in or around the main event, he gives 110%.  When he’s in the midcard, and he knows it, his performance level drops to match.  I can’t necessarily blame him for that, to be honest, but I also can’t sing his praises too highly, either.

19. Kalisto

Is Kalisto going to be the next Rey Mysterio?  Absolutely not.  Kalisto will never come anywhere close to the World title picture – At best, he’ll have a moment like Neville had on RAW, wrestling the world champion and maybe having a near fall or two.

That doesn’t mean Kalisto isn’t exciting and couldn’t be a WWE force for years to come, because he absolutely can.  He’s just being held down now as part of a tag team.  He really needs to go out on his own so he can show us all what he can truly do.

I like them. They’re the ones that I like.

18. Sheamus

I still see no reason why he should be holding the Money in the Bank briefcase, but I’m a fan of Sheamus, especially (in fact, exclusively) as currently packaged.  The Irish Viking look works for me, and he’s doing possibly some of his best work ever, character wise, in 2015.

Here’s a guy who could be bringing some prestige back to the IC title, especially if he held it for 6-8 months and helped elevate some talent as he did so.  I don’t want the Sheamus Open Challenge or anything, but feuds with guys like Kalisto, Cody Rhodes, Sandow and the like would be great for everyone involved.

17. Dean Ambrose

I’m not as high on Ambrose as just about everyone else in the world, and I’m OK with that. He’s had moments of brilliance, but he hasn’t had a string of impressive showings, both in ring or on camera, since he was hiding in trunks and taking taxi cabs to the ring.

Maybe that’s because WWE is a PG company, or maybe it’s because this character truly would be better as a heel.  You can’t be a Lunatic Fringe (whatever that is) and be a good guy at the same time.

This is why I remain steadfast with my prediction that Dean turns on Roman at Summer Slam, forming an unholy alliance with Bray Wyatt.  If I keep talking about it, maybe it’ll happen.  Let me dream, dang it!

16. Titus O’Neil

I’ve sung his praises for the last few days, and I mean every word of it, but that still doesn’t mean I’m hanging his picture up on my wall or anything.  Titus truly could be World Champion one day, but there’s still quite a bit of work that needs to happen before then.

Regardless, considering I didn’t even want O’Neil wasting NXT time a few months ago, I’d consider this a pretty healthy ranking for him.  If they keep giving him chances to talk and if he keeps being a bona fide superhero, who knows what his future holds?

15. John Cena

If 2015 was good to Titus O’Neil, in terms of my ranking, it was borderline miraculous for John Cena.  I don’t think any of us expected him to make the changes he did, and while he will be returning to the main event picture at Summer Slam (and, as I’ve written, will likely win the title), that still doesn’t change how much more respect fans have for him now than they did 6 months ago.

I won’t go buy any Cena merch, but when I do chant that “John Cena Sucks”, I’m definitely doing it ironically.

14. Brock Lesnar

Were I able to rank Lesnar and Heyman as a symbiotic pairing, they’d be much higher, as Paul Heyman continues to raise the bar on promos on an almost weekly basis.

On his own, though, while I like Brock a lot, I don’t love him.  Honestly, I just can’t get behind an unstoppable monster unless he, at some point in time, takes some punishment of his own.  This is, and I’m sorry Mr. Moltov, why I couldn’t get behind Goldberg, and why I’m so anti-Baron Corbin.  Lesnar might not be participating in squash matches, but its not that far off, either.  After you see one or two, you kinda get the idea of what he’s doing.

Hopefully, at Summer Slam, Taker will be able to keep him down for a while. I’m really hoping for an actual wrestling match, not a one-sided fight.

Hmm, finding issue with Brock Lesnar and hoping for him to get beaten down a bit by Undertaker.  I better stop this column here and give you time to send your hate mail and rotten produce my way.

Part 3 (the final part, I swear), will be up tomorrow.

Be sure to share your thoughts so far.  Be Heard.

From the NAI Archive – August 5, 2015 – Wacky Wednesday – Part 2 (of 3 ) of DC’s Top 40 Favorite WWE Superstars
Tagged on:             

Leave a Reply